Wednesday, May 17, 2006

More Linguists on Starlings and Recursion

Those of you still interested in the Gentner et al. paper on starlings learning a context-free grammar might want to read this letter submitted to Nature (and immediately rejected) by Ray Jackendoff, Mark Liberman, Geoff Pullum, and Barbara Scholz (via Language Log). This is the letter's conclusion:
The Gentner experiment may help us understand animal pattern recognition and learning abilities, some of them possibly prerequisites for linguistic abilities; but the implications are being considerably exaggerated, especially in popular media accounts with headlines like "Songbirds May Be Able to Learn Grammar."
Ray Jackendoff is definitely someone to take seriously when discussing issues related to the evolution of language (which is not to say that the others aren't; I'm just less familiar with their work). His book Foundations of Language is one of my favorites in cognitive science, largely because of the incredibly lucid and level-headed discussion of the evolution of language in Chatper 8. It may be the only evolution of language discussion out there with those qualities. It helps, of course, that Jackendoff backs it up with 7 chapters of theoretical discussion, clear even to a nonlinguist (though I wouldn't recommend it for people with no background in linguistics). So, when Jackendoff speaks on this topic, I listen.

13 comments:

Chris said...

How much of a linguistics background do you have? After the first couple chapters, it's pretty heavy, though very clear for nonlinguists.

Anonymous said...

maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons
maadloons

Manitoba Canada said...

You owe a very nice and interesting blog. Feel free to check out my site Manitoba, yellow page when you got time.

Nunavut Canada said...

Such interesting read and information, thanks for sharing this post. I will check back to read your other new posts. Please come visit my site Nunavut, business directory when you got time.

Cheryl said...

It helps, of course, that Jackendoff backs it up with 7 chapters of theoretical discussion, clear even to a nonlinguist.
Rocket French and Rocket Chinese

Kentucky laws Attorneys said...

Hey very nice blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…
State of Kentucky Lawyer Directory,
Kentucky Attorney Search,
Kentucky Lawyers Search, Find
A Kentucky Attorney Lawyers
, Kentucky Civil Law Attorneys, Kentucky Collection Law Attorneys, Kentucky Computers & Technology Law Attorneys, Kentucky Constitutional Law Attorneys, Kentucky Construction Law Attorneys, Kentucky Consumer Protection Attorneys, Kentucky Domestic Partnerships Attorneys, Kentucky Drug Charges Attorneys, Kentucky DUI/DWI Attorneys, Kentucky Education Law Attorneys, Kentucky Elder Law Attorneys, Kentucky Land Use & Zoning Attorneys, Kentucky Landlord & Tenant Law Attorneys, Kentucky Legal Information Services, Kentucky Legal Services, Kentucky Trial Attorneys, Kentucky Vehicular Accident Attorneys, Kentucky Whistleblower Attorneys, Kentucky Workers&#; Compensation Attorneys, Kentucky Wrongful Death Attorneys, Kentucky Wrongful Termination Attorneys

Louisiana laws Attorneys said...

This is very interesting information. I am doing some research for a class in school. and i liked the post. do you know where I can find other information regarding this? I am finding other information on this but nothing that I can use really in my paper for my final. do you have any suggestions?
State of Louisiana Lawyer Directory,
Louisiana Attorney Search,
Louisiana Lawyers Search, Find
A Louisiana Attorney Lawyers
, Louisiana Civil Law Attorneys, Louisiana Collection Law Attorneys, Louisiana Computers & Technology Law Attorneys, Louisiana Constitutional Law Attorneys, Louisiana Construction Law Attorneys, Louisiana Consumer Protection Attorneys, Louisiana Domestic Partnerships Attorneys, Louisiana Drug Charges Attorneys, Louisiana DUI/DWI Attorneys, Louisiana Education Law Attorneys, Louisiana Elder Law Attorneys, Louisiana Land Use & Zoning Attorneys, Louisiana Landlord & Tenant Law Attorneys, Louisiana Legal Information Services, Louisiana Legal Services, Louisiana Trial Attorneys, Louisiana Vehicular Accident Attorneys, Louisiana Whistleblower Attorneys, Louisiana Workers&#; Compensation Attorneys, Louisiana Wrongful Death Attorneys, Louisiana Wrongful Termination Attorneys

Lawyer Kentucky said...

Hey very nice blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…

Divorce
Attorney In Utah
, Divorce
Attorney In Virginia
, Divorce
Attorney In Washington
, Utah
Wrongful Death Attorney
, Virginia
Wrongful Death Attorney
, Washington Wrongful Death Attorney

Lawyer Louisiana said...

This is very interesting information. I am doing some research for a class in school. and i liked the post. do you know where I can find other information regarding this? I am finding other information on this but nothing that I can use really in my paper for my final. do you have any suggestions?
Mesothelioma Attorney Utah, Mesothelioma Attorney Virginia, Mesothelioma Attorney Washington, Attorney
At Utah
, Attorney
At Virginia
, Attorney
At Washington
, Divorce
Attorneys In Utah
, Divorce
Attorneys In Virginia

Unknown said...

found your site on del.icio.us today and really liked it.. i bookmarked it and will be back to check it out some more later .. pharmaceuticals, rv
for sale
, Salvation Army, Stores, Shopping
Mall, Shop
, grain storage prices, pharmaceutical industry

Unknown said...

Good writing. Keep up the good work. I just added your RSS feed my Google News Reader.. motorhome
rentals
, Flea Market, Antiques, Online
Shopping, Stores
, attraction
tourist
, grain storage elevator, pharmaceutical

Anonymous said...

As a Newbie, I am always searching online for articles that can help me. Thank you
San Diego Web Guide, Indianapolis Web Guide, Memphis Web Guide, Corpus Christi Web Guide, Lubbock Web Guide, Durham Web Guide

Anonymous said...

There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also.
San Diego Business Directory
Resources city guide
, Indianapolis Business Directory
Resources city guide
, Memphis Business Directory Resources city
guide